Home Cultura Havel kitsch

Havel kitsch

23
0

On the day Václav Havel would have turned 90, journalist and film maker Apolena Rychlíková mapped for Kapitál the changing perception of the playwright-turned-dissident-turned president, going back to the 1980s and one of Havel's earliest critics. Fellow dissident Petr Rezek disagreed with the main thesis of Havel's famous essay ‘The power of the powerless', arguing that – contra Havel – dissidents were not people willing to live in the truth, so much as people willing to live in conflict.

Following the Velvet Revolution and during and after his tenure as President, opinions on Havel's role and personality diverged, with neoliberals mocking him as an idealistic weakling and leftists regarding him as the epitome of anti-communist liberalism and moral kitsch. Meanwhile, liberals' adulation turned Havel's statement that ‘truth and love will prevail over lies and hatred' into a mantra.

Havel kitsch

Rychlíková describes herself as someone who has ‘passed through every phase, from uncritical acceptance – a consequence of growing up in a “Havelian family†– through disappointment to hypercritical distancingâ€. Havel's contradictions, she argues, ought to be accepted as part of his legacy.

On the one hand, he was a staunch champion of the environment, rights of minorities and human rights. In particular, he stood up for the Roma in amidst growing racism in the 1990s and helped draw attention to the Roma Holocaust, as well as by calling for critical reflection of the expulsion of the Germans from Czechoslovakia after World War II. On the other hand, Havel supported NATO strikes on Yugoslavia and the US-led invasion of Iraq and carries a share of responsibility for the direction the country took after 1989.

Rychlíková is repulsed by the recent attempts to turn Havel into a commercial brand that very nearly transformed the (now defunct) Václav Havel Library into a ‘tourist trap selling souvenirs in the shape of cuddly Havel toys in short trousers and wooden beer bottle openers emblazoned with his face …, gradually turning Havel's name into ptydepe, a term he coined in his play Memorandum for an artificial language created according to strict rules, meant to replace ordinary speech, which  gradually become divorced from the people and the actual message'.

Part of something bigger

Zuzana Šmilňáková writes that while the Serbian students' protests against large-scale government corruption were initially triggered by a specific event – the collapse of the canopy of the railway station in Novi Sad – their movement succeeded because they broadened their focus to the structural violence affecting society as a whole. In addition to demanding an investigation of the most egregious corruption cases, their election manifesto called for affordable housing and access to healthcare, which enabled the movement to connect with civic initiatives and trade unions across the country and across professional affiliations.

Just as importantly, the Serbian students made effective use of direct democracy with collective decision-making. A key tool for deciding on both operative and strategic issues, it was previously used in Croatia in 2008 and 2009 by students fighting for free university education, and by the civil movement fighting for better economic conditions in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 2014.

Šmilňáková challenges the lingering perception of ‘post-socialist, post-totalitarian and post-whatever' countries as immature and still reliant on western advice and democracy-building training programmes. This cliché, she believes, was put paid to by the Serbian students as they took on clientelism and the intertwining of state institutions with multinational business interests. What the students were up against was, in the author's view, ‘a violent structure keeping people in thrall to low wages and high living costs, combined with deteriorating and inaccessible social services'.

In recent years, thousands of people across the region, from workers in the factories of Bosnia and Herzegovina to protestors against the building of small hydropower plants in Serbia, have repeatedly united against such structures. In celebrating the students' victory, Šmilňáková concludes, ‘it is equally important to remember the dozens of movements that preceded it'.

Defying extinction

Writer and editor-in-chief of Kapitál Tomáš HuÄko recalls how last summer he saw his personal tragedy – his mother's death just seven weeks after being diagnosed with a rare neurodegenerative disease – converge with tragedies on a global scale. Trying to alleviate his mother's suffering as temperatures in Bratislava soared to 41 Celsius, HuÄko could not help but think of the multiple crises buffeting the world, from the escalating climate crisis to the war in Iran and the ongoing genocide in Gaza.

Echoing a line from a poem by Wallace Stevens, ‘death is the mother of beauty', HuÄko finds that witnessing death can open us to beauty, allowing us to see details we might otherwise miss: ‘I was acutely aware of the parallels between the fate that awaits all of us (but especially those who will come after us) in the world of extreme climate change and what sudden illness had in store for my mother. Both processes were brutally fast, much faster than predicted by experts. And while we can't prevent the death of our loved ones or the end of biodiversity, we can learn to accept it. Acceptance is not the same as resignation. It can be a creative, productive process that helps us to find a new meaning for ourselves, and – ideally – also for others.'

What gave HuÄko succour in the difficult times was a few books which brought at least some semblance of sense to this senseless world. They included Ed Simon's Writing During the Apocalypse. Reflections on the Great Unraveling, about the convergence of the personal and the global; Eva Kantůrková's PřítelkynÄ› z domu smutku (‘Friends from the House of Sadness'), about imprisonment under Czechoslovakia's ‘normalisation' regime; and Nicol Hochholczerová's Tam (‘There'), about coming to terms with the death of a grandfather. What helped HuÄko was simply knowing these books exist, ‘that someone is making art in defiance of the difficult, critical and tragic circumstances and that these works communicate with others, even across the chasm of time, space and death'.

Review by Julia Sherwood